Worth a Journey

Read by 254k monthly readers

The World’s 100 Best Ice Cream Parlours

Blacksmith Ice Cream Co.

Millcreek, United States

  1. WORLD’S BEST ICE CREAM PARLOURS WORTH A JOURNEY · 2026 ✦ ✦ N° 87 2026
Blacksmith Ice Cream Co.

Ice cream shop in Millcreek making its ice cream in-house, with permanent flavours plus monthly and seasonal ones. Honey lavender, dough and cookies, cookie butter and s'mores are the standout flavours, and the dairy-free flavours taste like dairy ice cream.

Highlights

  • Honeybud and dough and cookies
  • Made in-house, rotating flavours
  • Upstairs loft seating area

Good to know

  • Lines out the door, move quickly
  • Dairy-free options, limited gluten-free choice
  • Small parking lot, limited seating

Also in the United States

  1. Scoops N Sliders N° 63 Scoops N Sliders Pocatello Ice cream parlour
  2. Gelateria Degli Angeli N° 64 Gelateria Degli Angeli Sarasota Gelateria
  3. Made In Rome Organic Gelato N° 68 Made In Rome Organic Gelato Siesta Key Gelateria
  4. Germano’s Premium Gelato N° 76 Germano’s Premium Gelato Pompton Plains Gelateria
  5. Dua Gelato & Coffee N° 83 Dua Gelato & Coffee Lighthouse Point Gelateria
  6. V Gelato & Cafe N° 95 V Gelato & Cafe Miami Gelateria